王毅翔：If the reviewer is good, then expert reviewer can find the problems in the proposal, while those reviewers who are not expert in this field, or did not read the proposal carefully, usually give good comments 2015-08-26 15:56
王毅翔：we all know to get grants is like to buy lottery. it depends on luck. in any places.
- I do not know. you better ask other experts.
- in Hong Kong, we need to explain why last application is failed and better to start a new one.
王毅翔：many proposals are not read by the reviewers carefully. I heard many are read by junior graduate students.
therefore I advocate:
we have to admit the world is not perfect. 2015-08-26 15:09
王毅翔：this world is not fair, not perfect. we need to accept this point. you ask ask your colleagues what should be 人员结构不合理.
I think it is important that the applicant can do rebuttal and do minor changes,
see my post on Romanian procedures 2015-08-26 15:05